Nostalgic Candy

Showing 1–24 of 108 results

Default sorting Sort by popularity Sort by average rating Sort by latest Sort by price: low to high Sort by price: high to low

• 

  5th Avenue Candy Bars: 18-Piece Box

  $39.50 Original price was: $39.50.$25.68Current price is: $25.68. Add to bag
• 

  6-Flavor Assortment Hard Candy Sticks: 100-Piece Box

  $76.50 Original price was: $76.50.$49.73Current price is: $49.73. Add to bag
• 

  Abba Zaba Chocolate & Peanut Butter Bar: 24 Pack

  $47.95 Original price was: $47.95.$31.17Current price is: $31.17. Add to bag
• 

  Abba-Zaba Mystery Flavor Candy Bars: 24-Piece Box

  $35.50 Original price was: $35.50.$23.08Current price is: $23.08. Add to bag
• 

  AirHeads Striped Taffy Mini Candy Bars Packs: 12-Piece Box

  $35.50 Original price was: $35.50.$23.08Current price is: $23.08. Add to bag
• 

  AirHeads Taffy Candy Bars - Pink Lemonade: 36-Piece Box

  $14.95 Original price was: $14.95.$9.72Current price is: $9.72. Add to bag
• 

  AirHeads Taffy Mini Candy Bars - Blue Raspberry: 25LB Case

  $105.50 Original price was: $105.50.$68.58Current price is: $68.58. Add to bag
• 

  AirHeads Taffy Mini Candy Bars - Blue Raspberry: 5LB Bag

  $28.95 Original price was: $28.95.$18.82Current price is: $18.82. Add to bag
• 

  AirHeads Taffy Mini Candy Bars - Cherry: 25LB Case

  $105.50 Original price was: $105.50.$68.58Current price is: $68.58. Add to bag
• 

  AirHeads Taffy Mini Candy Bars - Cherry: 5LB Bag

  $28.95 Original price was: $28.95.$18.82Current price is: $18.82. Add to bag
• 

  AirHeads Taffy Mini Candy Bars - Watermelon: 5LB Bag

  $28.95 Original price was: $28.95.$18.82Current price is: $18.82. Add to bag
• 

  AirHeads Taffy Mini Sours Assorted Candy Bars: 5LB Bag

  $27.50 Original price was: $27.50.$17.88Current price is: $17.88. Add to bag
• 

  Almond Joy Candy Bars: 24-Piece Box

  $48.50 Original price was: $48.50.$31.53Current price is: $31.53. Add to bag
• 

  Almond Joy Snack Size Candy Bars: 18-Piece Bag

  $9.50 Original price was: $9.50.$6.18Current price is: $6.18. Add to bag
• 

  Andes Mints Creme De Menthe Chocolate Candy: 12-Piece Case

  $49.95 Original price was: $49.95.$32.47Current price is: $32.47. Add to bag
• 

  Andes Mints Creme de Menthe: 240-Piece Tub

  $29.50 Original price was: $29.50.$19.18Current price is: $19.18. Add to bag
• 

  Anise Bears Candy: 5LB Bag

  $17.95 Original price was: $17.95.$11.67Current price is: $11.67. Add to bag
• 

  Annabelle's Abba-Zaba Candy Bars: 24-Piece Box

  $54.95 Original price was: $54.95.$35.72Current price is: $35.72. Add to bag
• 

  Annabelle's Abba-Zaba Mini Chunks: 10LB Case

  $104.95 Original price was: $104.95.$68.22Current price is: $68.22. Add to bag
• 

  Annabelle's Big Hunk Candy Bars: 24-Piece Box

  $35.50 Original price was: $35.50.$23.08Current price is: $23.08. Add to bag
• 

  Annabelle's Big Hunk Mini Chunks: 10LB Case

  $104.95 Original price was: $104.95.$68.22Current price is: $68.22. Add to bag
• 

  Annabelle's Candy Snack Size Bars Assortment: 70-Piece Bag

  $23.50 Original price was: $23.50.$15.28Current price is: $15.28. Add to bag
• 

  Applehead Candy Mini Packs: 24-Piece Box

  $7.50 Original price was: $7.50.$4.88Current price is: $4.88. Add to bag
• 

  Arcor Bon o Bon Peanut Butter Filled Butter Toffees Candy: 1LB Bag

  $11.95 Original price was: $11.95.$7.77Current price is: $7.77. Add to bag