Free shipping on orders of $25+. Under $25, standard shipping is $6 (3–5 days) or express is $9.99 (1–2 days).

Old Fashioned Penny Candy

Old Fashioned Penny Candy

Showing 1–24 of 233 results

Apple-Filled Vanilla Caramels: 5-Pound Bag
Original price was: $25.95.Current price is: $16.87. Add to bag
Arcor Butterscotch Buttons: 6LB Bag
Original price was: $24.50.Current price is: $15.93. Add to bag
Arcor Chewy Fruities Candy: 6-Ounce Bag
Original price was: $4.50.Current price is: $2.93. Add to bag
Arcor Honey Filled Hard Candy: 6-Pound Bag
Original price was: $28.95.Current price is: $18.82. Add to bag
Assorted Salt Water Taffy Candy: 3LB Bag
Original price was: $18.50.Current price is: $12.03. Add to bag
Atkinson Anise Squares Hard Candy: 5LB Bag
Original price was: $28.95.Current price is: $18.82. Add to bag
Atkinson Black Licorice Hard Candy Balls: 5LB Bag
Original price was: $28.95.Current price is: $18.82. Add to bag
Atkinson Cherry Hard Candy Buttons: 5LB Bag
Original price was: $28.95.Current price is: $18.82. Add to bag
Atkinson Chick-O-Stick Nuggets Candy: 3LB Bag
Original price was: $24.50.Current price is: $15.93. Add to bag
Atkinson Chick-O-Stick Original Candy: 160-Piece Jar
Original price was: $42.50.Current price is: $27.63. Add to bag
Atkinson Coconut Long Boys Juniors Candy: 2LB Case
Original price was: $32.95.Current price is: $21.42. Add to bag
Atkinson Hard Candy Twists - Fruitie Tootie: 5LB Bag
Original price was: $28.95.Current price is: $18.82. Add to bag
Atkinson Hard Candy Twists - Peppermint: 5LB Bag
Original price was: $38.90.Current price is: $25.29. Add to bag
Atkinson Hard Candy Twists - Rainbow Cherry: 5LB Bag
Original price was: $28.95.Current price is: $18.82. Add to bag
Atkinson Hard Candy Twists - Wintergreen: 5LB Bag
Original price was: $28.95.Current price is: $18.82. Add to bag
Atkinson Hot Cinnamon Hard Candy Buttons: 5LB Bag
Original price was: $28.95.Current price is: $18.82. Add to bag
Atkinson Leman's Mint Footballs Hard Candy: 5LB Bag
Original price was: $34.95.Current price is: $22.72. Add to bag
Atkinson Leman's Mint Hard Candy Buttons: 5LB Bag
Original price was: $34.95.Current price is: $22.72. Add to bag
Atkinson Lemon Slices Hard Candy: 5LB Bag
Original price was: $28.95.Current price is: $18.82. Add to bag
Atkinson Long Boys Coconut Bars Candy: 24-Piece Display
Original price was: $54.50.Current price is: $35.43. Add to bag
Atkinson Old Fashioned Honeycombed Peanuts Candy: 5LB Bag
Original price was: $28.95.Current price is: $18.82. Add to bag
Atkinson Orange Slices Hard Candy: 5LB Bag
Original price was: $28.95.Current price is: $18.82. Add to bag
Atkinson Peanut Butter Bars Candy: 3LB Bag
Original price was: $24.50.Current price is: $15.93. Add to bag
Atkinson Peanut Butter Hard Candy Balls: 5LB Bag
Original price was: $28.95.Current price is: $18.82. Add to bag