Free shipping on orders of $25+. Under $25, standard shipping is $6 (3–5 days) or express is $9.99 (1–2 days).

Old Fashioned Taffy

Old Fashioned Taffy

Showing 25–48 of 136 results

Now and Later Soft Fruit Chews Candy Packs - Apple: 24-Piece Box
Original price was: $14.50.Current price is: $9.43. Add to bag
Now and Later Soft Fruit Chews Candy Packs - Grape: 24-Piece Box
Original price was: $14.50.Current price is: $9.43. Add to bag
Now and Later Soft Fruit Chews Candy Packs - Pineapple: 24-Piece Box
Original price was: $14.50.Current price is: $9.43. Add to bag
Orange Vanilla Creamsicle Salt Water Taffy: 3LB Bag
Original price was: $18.50.Current price is: $12.03. Add to bag
Peach Salt Water Taffy: 3LB Bag
Original price was: $18.50.Current price is: $12.03. Add to bag
Peppermint Salt Water Taffy: 3LB Bag
Original price was: $18.50.Current price is: $12.03. Add to bag
Pineapple Ginger Salt Water Taffy: 3LB Bag
Original price was: $18.50.Current price is: $12.03. Add to bag
Root Beer Salt Water Taffy: 3LB Bag
Original price was: $18.50.Current price is: $12.03. Add to bag
Salt Water Taffy - Apple Pie: 2.5LB Bag
Original price was: $13.50.Current price is: $8.78. Add to bag
Salt Water Taffy - Apricot: 2.5LB Bag
Original price was: $13.50.Current price is: $8.78. Add to bag
Salt Water Taffy - Banana Creme: 2.5LB Bag
Original price was: $13.50.Current price is: $8.78. Add to bag
Salt Water Taffy - Banana Split: 2.5LB Bag
Original price was: $14.50.Current price is: $9.43. Add to bag
Salt Water Taffy - Banana: 2.5LB Bag
Original price was: $13.50.Current price is: $8.78. Add to bag
Salt Water Taffy - Berry Creme Assortment: 5LB Bag
Original price was: $22.95.Current price is: $14.92. Add to bag
Salt Water Taffy - Black Licorice Swirl: 2.5LB Bag
Original price was: $13.50.Current price is: $8.78. Add to bag
Salt Water Taffy - Blue Raspberry: 2.5LB Bag
Original price was: $13.50.Current price is: $8.78. Add to bag
Salt Water Taffy - Blueberry Muffin: 2.5LB Bag
Original price was: $13.50.Current price is: $8.78. Add to bag
Salt Water Taffy - Blueberry: 2.5LB Bag
Original price was: $13.50.Current price is: $8.78. Add to bag
Salt Water Taffy - Bubble Gum: 2.5LB Bag
Original price was: $13.50.Current price is: $8.78. Add to bag
Salt Water Taffy - Buttered Popcorn: 2.5LB Bag
Original price was: $13.50.Current price is: $8.78. Add to bag
Salt Water Taffy - Butterscotch Wizards Brew: 2.5LB Bag
Original price was: $13.50.Current price is: $8.78. Add to bag
Salt Water Taffy - Candy Apple: 2.5LB Bag
Original price was: $13.50.Current price is: $8.78. Add to bag
Salt Water Taffy - Candy Corn: 2.5LB Bag
Original price was: $13.50.Current price is: $8.78. Add to bag
Salt Water Taffy - Cantaloupe: 2.5LB Bag
Original price was: $13.50.Current price is: $8.78. Add to bag