Free shipping on orders of $25+. Under $25, standard shipping is $6 (3–5 days) or express is $9.99 (1–2 days).

Peanut Butter Candy

Peanut Butter Candy

Showing 25–48 of 239 results

Atkinson Chick-O-Stick Nuggets Candy: 3LB Bag
Original price was: $24.50.Current price is: $15.93. Add to bag
Atkinson Chick-O-Stick Original Candy: 160-Piece Jar
Original price was: $42.50.Current price is: $27.63. Add to bag
Atkinson Chick-O-Stick Original Nuggets Candy: 160-Piece Tub
Original price was: $18.95.Current price is: $12.32. Add to bag
Atkinson Old Fashioned Honeycombed Peanuts Candy: 5LB Bag
Original price was: $28.95.Current price is: $18.82. Add to bag
Atkinson Peanut Butter Bar Candy Bars: 36-Piece Box
Original price was: $24.50.Current price is: $15.93. Add to bag
Atkinson Peanut Butter Bars 3-Ounce Peg Bags: 12-Piece Case
Original price was: $32.50.Current price is: $21.13. Add to bag
Atkinson Peanut Butter Bars Candy: 3LB Bag
Original price was: $24.50.Current price is: $15.93. Add to bag
Atkinson Peanut Butter Hard Candy Balls: 5LB Bag
Original price was: $28.95.Current price is: $18.82. Add to bag
Atkinson Peanut Butter Sticks Candy: 160-Piece Jar
Original price was: $44.50.Current price is: $28.93. Add to bag
Atkinson Sugar Free Chick-O-Stick Original Candy Nuggets: 3LB Bag
Original price was: $34.95.Current price is: $22.72. Add to bag
Atkinson Sugar Free Peanut Butter Bars Candy: 3LB Bag
Original price was: $34.95.Current price is: $22.72. Add to bag
A’cappella Knotty Grahams Chocolate Peanut Butter Knots: 6-Pack
Original price was: $37.95.Current price is: $24.67. Add to bag
Baby Ruth Candy Bars: 24-Piece Box
Original price was: $58.50.Current price is: $38.03. Add to bag
Baby Ruth Mini Size Candy Bars: 5LB Bag
Original price was: $40.50.Current price is: $26.33. Add to bag
Belles Gourmet Candy Popcorn - Peanut Butter Crunch: 12-Piece Case
Original price was: $48.50.Current price is: $31.53. Add to bag
Bobo's Peanut Butter & Jelly Stuff’d Bites: 25-Piece Box
Original price was: $38.50.Current price is: $25.03. Add to bag
Bobo's Strawberry Stuff’d Bites: 25-Piece Box
Original price was: $38.50.Current price is: $25.03. Add to bag
Boston Baked Beans Candy Mini Packs: 24-Piece Box
Original price was: $19.50.Current price is: $12.68. Add to bag
Brach's Chocolate Bridge Mix Candy: 8-Ounce Bag
Original price was: $5.95.Current price is: $3.87. Add to bag
Brach's Double Dippers Milk Chocolate Covered Peanuts: 12-Ounce Bag
Original price was: $8.50.Current price is: $5.53. Add to bag
Brach's Milk & Dark Chocolate Caramel & Nut Mix Candy: 8-Ounce Bag
Original price was: $5.95.Current price is: $3.87. Add to bag
Brach's Milk Chocolate Peanut Clusters Candy: 10-Ounce Bag
Original price was: $8.50.Current price is: $5.53. Add to bag
Butterfinger Bites: 8-Ounce Bag
Original price was: $6.95.Current price is: $4.52. Add to bag
Butterfinger Candy Bars: 36-Piece Box
Original price was: $84.50.Current price is: $54.93. Add to bag