Free shipping on orders of $25+. Under $25, standard shipping is $6 (3–5 days) or express is $9.99 (1–2 days).

Peanut Butter Candy

Peanut Butter Candy

Showing 49–72 of 239 results

Butterfinger French Toast Bars: 18-Piece Box
Original price was: $57.50.Current price is: $37.38. Add to bag
Butterfinger Fun Size Candy Bars Assortment: 35.9-Ounce Bag
Original price was: $23.50.Current price is: $15.28. Add to bag
Butterfinger Fun Size Candy Bars Assortment: 40-Piece Bag
Original price was: $18.95.Current price is: $12.32. Add to bag
Butterfinger Fun Size Candy Bars: 16-Piece Bag
Original price was: $9.95.Current price is: $6.47. Add to bag
Butterfinger Fun Size Peanut Butter Cups: 10.5-Ounce Bag
Original price was: $7.95.Current price is: $5.17. Add to bag
Butterfinger Giant Size Candy Bars: 12-Piece Box
Original price was: $42.50.Current price is: $27.63. Add to bag
Butterfinger King Size Candy Bars: 18-Piece Box
Original price was: $68.50.Current price is: $44.53. Add to bag
Butterfinger Mini Size Candy Bars: 5LB Bag
Original price was: $40.50.Current price is: $26.33. Add to bag
Butterfinger Peanut Butter Cups Candy Packs: 24-Piece Box
Original price was: $35.50.Current price is: $23.08. Add to bag
Butterfinger Unwrapped Minis Chocolate Theater Box: 9-Piece Display
Original price was: $19.50.Current price is: $12.68. Add to bag
Candy Pop PB&J Jiff Smuckers Candy Popcorn: 12-Piece Case
Original price was: $92.50.Current price is: $60.13. Add to bag
Chocolove Salted Peanut Butter Milk Chocolate Candy Bars: 10-Piece Box
Original price was: $62.00.Current price is: $40.30. Add to bag
Clark Candy Bars: 24-Piece Box
Original price was: $86.50.Current price is: $56.23. Add to bag
Clark Peanut Butter Cups: 24-Piece Box
Original price was: $49.50.Current price is: $32.18. Add to bag
Crushed Butterfinger Candy Bars: 5LB Bag
Original price was: $46.50.Current price is: $30.23. Add to bag
Dove Dark Chocolate Peanut Butter Squares: 24-Piece Bag
Original price was: $9.95.Current price is: $6.47. Add to bag
Dove Milk Chocolate Peanut Butter Squares: 24-Piece Bag
Original price was: $9.95.Current price is: $6.47. Add to bag
Feastables Peanut Butter Candy Bar: 24-Piece Box
Original price was: $119.50.Current price is: $77.68. Add to bag
Fralinger's Peanut Butter Taffy Chews Candy: 12-Ounce Box
Original price was: $17.95.Current price is: $11.67. Add to bag
Go Max Go 2fer Candy Bar: 12-Piece Box
Original price was: $44.50.Current price is: $28.93. Add to bag
Go Max Go Cleo’s Vegan Peanut Butter Cups: 12-Piece Box
Original price was: $44.50.Current price is: $28.93. Add to bag
Go Max Go Cleo’s White Peanut Butter Cups: 12-Piece Box
Original price was: $44.50.Current price is: $28.93. Add to bag
Go Max Go Thumbs Up Vegan Candy Bar: 12-Piece Box
Original price was: $44.50.Current price is: $28.93. Add to bag
Goo Goo Clusters - Cheerwine: 12-Piece Box
Original price was: $32.95.Current price is: $21.42. Add to bag